{"guid":"2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","title":"Algorithmic science evaluation and power structure: the discourse on strategic citation and 'citation cartels'","subtitle":null,"slug":"34c3-9030-algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels","link":"https://fahrplan.events.ccc.de/congress/2017/Fahrplan/events/9030.html","description":"Quantitative science evaluation, such as university rankings, rely on man-made algorithms and man-made databases. The modelling decisions underlying this data-driven algorithmic science evaluation are, among other things, the outcome of a specific power structure in the science system. Power relations are especially visible, when negotiated during processes of boundary work. Therefore, we use the discourse on 'citation cartels', to shed light on a specific perception of fairness in the scientific system, as well as on the actors who are in charge. While doing so, we draw analogies to the discourse on search engine optimization.","original_language":"eng","persons":["J. Hartstein","Teresa Isigkeit","Franziska Sörgel"],"view_count":592,"promoted":false,"date":"2017-12-27T00:00:00.000+01:00","release_date":"2017-12-28T01:00:00.000+01:00","updated_at":"2026-01-09T19:45:21.109+01:00","tags":["34c3","9030","Science"],"length":1886,"duration":1886,"thumb_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/congress/2017/9030-hd.jpg","poster_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/congress/2017/9030-hd_preview.jpg","timeline_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/congress/2017/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475-timeline.jpg","thumbnails_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/congress/2017/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475-thumbnails.vtt","frontend_link":"https://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-9030-algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_title":"34C3: TUWAT","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3","related":[{"event_id":4762,"event_guid":"b036385c-ec1a-44e5-ae48-af703ce9b5d3","weight":27},{"event_id":4763,"event_guid":"2ef3b60f-6e5c-4c23-a145-d263685ec13e","weight":31},{"event_id":4767,"event_guid":"f2ca3661-30c8-476e-9d6b-920bb20b21eb","weight":16},{"event_id":4770,"event_guid":"a890dbd3-8859-4788-a72f-ded5c5c08e5f","weight":21},{"event_id":4774,"event_guid":"6588e4a4-d0ac-4082-ad9e-7a13329217ee","weight":30},{"event_id":4779,"event_guid":"544e7736-6b59-4c05-87a7-c013ef993688","weight":5},{"event_id":4781,"event_guid":"44e7cb13-011e-4242-b26a-1edf4ac15b83","weight":26},{"event_id":4782,"event_guid":"de1b5916-8052-4a25-bded-25d96a43aff7","weight":26},{"event_id":4791,"event_guid":"8d29d28d-a222-4731-bdfc-fde590385cae","weight":17},{"event_id":4794,"event_guid":"a2887b4a-0c9d-4220-a52f-c65c20ae25d7","weight":27},{"event_id":4800,"event_guid":"a9ebf7e3-abc5-49d9-8efe-316b3bc52902","weight":26},{"event_id":4804,"event_guid":"0cccbcdd-1e5c-4457-883b-6141c04d754c","weight":76},{"event_id":4805,"event_guid":"ed1d9ef6-23e1-4213-be8d-b97625ff20da","weight":11},{"event_id":4808,"event_guid":"acab4111-aba7-44f7-b56e-ef805dcacd00","weight":32},{"event_id":4816,"event_guid":"1d7b2355-60b1-453c-bf0e-64228466d2cc","weight":19},{"event_id":4821,"event_guid":"aed02b65-9a16-4a42-ac28-2883da680d0a","weight":20},{"event_id":4826,"event_guid":"16645200-2036-4a3c-a44d-a5ff44ac2991","weight":39},{"event_id":4828,"event_guid":"4cb7be14-bfbd-42a2-a556-9ef8e8bd6ba7","weight":12},{"event_id":4850,"event_guid":"949bee69-3be0-4cc8-915b-5f1167141dcc","weight":37},{"event_id":4857,"event_guid":"5cbe3344-f83a-492d-afc2-f1697959ff5e","weight":27},{"event_id":4866,"event_guid":"117a52b4-f675-49dd-aafe-659c07b6bc9c","weight":42}],"recordings":[{"size":null,"length":null,"mime_type":"application/x-subrip","language":"eng","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.en.srt","state":"complete","folder":"","high_quality":true,"width":null,"height":null,"updated_at":"2020-01-03T19:23:35.036+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.en.srt","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/44458","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":150,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.mp4","state":"new","folder":"h264-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T16:00:14.777+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/h264-hd/34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/20968","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":151,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"deu","filename":"34c3-9030-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.mp4","state":"new","folder":"h264-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T16:00:21.755+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/h264-hd/34c3-9030-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/20969","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":208,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng-deu","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_hd.mp4","state":"new","folder":"h264-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T16:00:29.234+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/h264-hd/34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_hd.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/20970","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":94,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng-deu","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_sd.mp4","state":"new","folder":"h264-sd","high_quality":false,"width":720,"height":576,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T16:30:22.912+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/h264-sd/34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_sd.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/21000","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":88,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng-deu","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_hd-slides.mp4","state":"new","folder":"slides-h264-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T16:58:57.585+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/slides-h264-hd/34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_hd-slides.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/21032","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":146,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/webm","language":"eng-deu","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_webm-sd.webm","state":"new","folder":"webm-sd","high_quality":false,"width":720,"height":576,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T17:25:09.537+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/webm-sd/34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_webm-sd.webm","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/21078","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":19,"length":1871,"mime_type":"audio/opus","language":"eng","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.opus","state":"new","folder":"opus","high_quality":false,"width":0,"height":0,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T20:14:37.380+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/opus/34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.opus","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/21131","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":28,"length":1871,"mime_type":"audio/mpeg","language":"eng","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.mp3","state":"new","folder":"mp3","high_quality":false,"width":0,"height":0,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T20:15:09.060+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/mp3/34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels.mp3","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/21132","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":307,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/webm","language":"eng-deu","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_webm-hd.webm","state":"new","folder":"webm-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2017-12-28T21:13:13.541+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/webm-hd/34c3-9030-eng-deu-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_webm-hd.webm","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/21225","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"},{"size":36,"length":1886,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng","filename":"34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_sd-slides.mp4","state":"new","folder":"slides-h264-sd","high_quality":false,"width":720,"height":576,"updated_at":"2018-01-02T15:21:17.456+01:00","recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/congress/2017/slides-h264-sd/34c3-9030-eng-Algorithmic_science_evaluation_and_power_structure_the_discourse_on_strategic_citation_and_citation_cartels_sd-slides.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/22259","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/2024d7d1-4510-4371-a923-3dabdb408475","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/34c3"}]}