{"guid":"a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","title":"Maybe it is time to consider layer 3 internet exchanges","subtitle":null,"slug":"denog18-95-maybe-it-is-time-to-consider-layer-3-internet-exchanges","link":"https://cfp.denog.de/denog18/talk/EMHXW7/","description":"Internet exchanges have presented as shared layer 2 networks for thirty years. I will show the mechanisms that silently blackhole exchange traffic or forward it to the wrong port: missing or incorrect neighbour entries, and unknown unicast flooding. In each case BGP stays established to the route servers and nothing reports a fault.\n\nA large exchange stated in writing that it gives no guarantee traffic sent to a peering LAN goes to, and only to, the port of the network it was meant for, and that it knows of no exchange that does. I do not know how many members expect that answer.\n\nThe rest of the industry has spent years dismantling large layer 2 domains in favour of routed ones. Perhaps it is time for internet exchanges to forward at layer 3, rather than running a layer 2 forwarding domain with a route server making routing decisions.\n\nIn many cases this needs no new hardware. The switches already used to build exchange fabrics forward at layer 2 and at layer 3 at line rate. Route scale is where careful consideration is needed.\n\nThe shape of a layer 3 internet exchange switch is already commonplace: each PNI switch a CDN or ISP operates is a routed exchange with several settlement-free peers and one customer on it.\n\nRunning at layer 3 gives participants complete isolation between ports, the same model that already applies to every other upstream connection that networks buy. RTBH works at the exchange rather than depending on a peer to honour it. Debugging becomes possible from the participant side, because traceroute shows the exchange hop.\n\nLicensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0","original_language":"eng","persons":["James Rice"],"view_count":115,"promoted":false,"date":"2026-11-17T09:30:00.000+01:00","release_date":"2026-11-17T00:00:00.000+01:00","updated_at":"2026-11-20T17:45:08.418+01:00","tags":["EMHXW7","2026","denog18","Saal B","denog18-eng","Day 3"],"length":1103,"duration":1103,"thumb_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/events/denog/denog18/95-a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e.jpg","poster_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/events/denog/denog18/95-a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e_preview.jpg","timeline_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/events/denog/denog18/95-a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e.timeline.jpg","thumbnails_url":"https://static.media.ccc.de/media/events/denog/denog18/95-a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e.thumbnails.vtt","frontend_link":"https://media.ccc.de/v/denog18-95-maybe-it-is-time-to-consider-layer-3-internet-exchanges","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_title":"DENOG18","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18","related":[],"recordings":[{"length":1103,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_hd.mp4","state":"new","folder":"h264-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:09:13.895+01:00","label":"eng 1080p","size":153,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/h264-hd/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_hd.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107549","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"audio/mpeg","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_mp3.mp3","state":"new","folder":"mp3","high_quality":false,"width":0,"height":0,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:16:02.912+01:00","label":"eng","size":17,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/mp3/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_mp3.mp3","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107550","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"audio/opus","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_opus.opus","state":"new","folder":"opus","high_quality":false,"width":0,"height":0,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:17:06.310+01:00","label":"eng","size":10,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/opus/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_opus.opus","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107552","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"video/mp4","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_sd.mp4","state":"new","folder":"h264-sd","high_quality":false,"width":720,"height":576,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:18:03.423+01:00","label":"eng 576p","size":41,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/h264-sd/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_sd.mp4","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107553","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"video/webm","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_webm-sd.webm","state":"new","folder":"webm-sd","high_quality":false,"width":720,"height":576,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:35:28.244+01:00","label":"eng 576p","size":39,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/webm-sd/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_webm-sd.webm","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107560","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"video/webm;codecs=av01","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_av1-sd.webm","state":"new","folder":"av1-sd","high_quality":false,"width":720,"height":576,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:23:17.928+01:00","label":"eng 576p","size":34,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/av1-sd/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_av1-sd.webm","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107555","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"video/webm;codecs=av01","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_av1-hd.webm","state":"new","folder":"av1-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:23:42.304+01:00","label":"eng 1080p","size":112,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/av1-hd/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_av1-hd.webm","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107556","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"},{"length":1103,"mime_type":"video/webm","language":"eng","filename":"denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_webm-hd.webm","state":"new","folder":"webm-hd","high_quality":true,"width":1920,"height":1080,"updated_at":"2026-11-17T12:35:04.838+01:00","label":"eng 1080p","size":122,"recording_url":"https://cdn.media.ccc.de/events/denog/denog18/webm-hd/denog18-95-eng-Maybe_it_is_time_to_consider_layer_3_internet_exchanges_webm-hd.webm","url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/recordings/107558","event_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/events/a5c403a5-b258-5f96-9670-78360f3d5a5e","conference_url":"https://api.media.ccc.de/public/conferences/denog18"}]}